Can I Guess the Agave? Don Amado Mezcal Blind Tasting!
Can I actually identify different agave varieties if you take the labels off?
Today, I'm putting that question to the test with a blind tasting of Don Amado Mezcal.
I have four different Don Amado expressions poured completely blind, including Arroqueño, Tepeztate, Tobalá & Bicuishe, and Largo, with Rústico serving as a familiar Espadín-based reference. Don Amado produces these mezcals in Santa Catarina Minas, Oaxaca, using traditional production methods that allow the agave and the production process to shine through.
The goal is simple: Can I actually recognize the different agave varieties based only on aroma and flavor?
In this blind tasting, I look for differences in:
Cooked agave
Vegetal characteristics
Citrus and fruit
Floral aromas
Earthiness and minerality
️ Pepper and spice
Roasted agave character
Tropical fruit and other unique flavors
What makes this experiment so interesting is that the producer and general production philosophy remain consistent, while the agave variety changes. Don Amado uses traditional earthen roasting, fermentation with natural airborne yeast, and double distillation in ceramic pot stills.
And the big question is:
Can I really tell which agave I'm drinking without seeing the label?
Watch the full blind tasting to see how many I get right—and whether I can actually recognize the characteristics I've learned from drinking these mezcals.
I also talk about how repeatedly tasting different agave varieties has helped me train my palate and better understand what makes each expression unique.
If you've ever done a blind mezcal tasting, I'd love to know: Could you identify the agave varieties without seeing the bottles?
Tell me your results in the comments!
Cheers, and have a fantastic night.
© Tasting Tequila with Brad
Tequila NOM number explained! Learn what a NOM number is, how to read a NOM number on tequila bottles, and why the tequila NOM...
Bandero Reposado Review: 3 Types of Oak, 11 Months — Worth It?Is Bandero Limited Edition Reposado worth it? In this tequila review, we explore...
Every batch tastes different — and today I’m reviewing Terra de Ensueño Tequila Batch 5. This tequila review explains why tequila batch numbers matter,...