Cayeya Reposado Tequila Review: 6 Months in Oak & Recycled Beer Bottles

September 12, 2026 00:03:58
Cayeya Reposado Tequila Review: 6 Months in Oak & Recycled Beer Bottles
Tasting Tequila with Brad
Cayeya Reposado Tequila Review: 6 Months in Oak & Recycled Beer Bottles

Sep 12 2026 | 00:03:58

/

Show Notes

Cayeya Reposado Tequila Review: 6 Months in Oak & Recycled Beer Bottles

What happens when the same tequila goes from Blanco to Reposado and spends six months in oak? Today, we're finding out with Cayeya Reposado.

I recently reviewed Cayeya Blanco, and now we're taking a closer look at what six months in a combination of American and French oak barrels does to this tequila.

Cayeya is produced at NOM 1424 in San Juanito de Escobedo by master distiller Zandra Gomez, using 100% Blue Weber Agave.

But the production story gets especially interesting when we look at how the agave is extracted.

Cayeya uses a roller mill combined with a screw mill system. After cooking, the roller mill crushes and shreds the agave, while the large screw mill continuously pushes the cooked fibers forward under pressure, helping squeeze out more of the sugary agave juice.

The tequila is fermented in stainless steel tanks without agave fibers, using deep well water, and is then double distilled before spending six months in American and French oak.

And then there's the bottle.

Cayeya Reposado is bottled in recycled Pacifico beer bottles. The recycled glass gives the bottle its distinctive color, while the handcrafted process at a family-owned artisanal glass factory in Jalisco means each bottle can have its own small variations and imperfections.

Cayeya carries that sustainability idea throughout the packaging, with the glass, cork, hang tag, and other elements made from recycled materials.

But as always, the real question is what's inside the bottle.

On the nose, I find cooked agave, caramel, vanilla, herbal notes, grassiness, and citrus, with a character that reminds me of lemongrass mixed with caramel, vanilla, and oak.

On the palate, there's cooked agave, pepper, sweetness, caramel, vanilla, and a grassy herbal character. The finish becomes peppery and sweet, with a touch of oak and a slight dryness. With a second taste, I also pick up some citrus, fruitiness, and floral notes.

For me, the Cayeya Reposado is a much more impressive presentation than the Blanco. The combination of French and American oak has clearly changed the flavor profile while keeping the tequila balanced and agave-driven.

This is a tequila I'd happily sip neat rather than put into a cocktail.

So, have you tried Cayeya Reposado? Would you drink it?

Let me know what you think in the comments.

Cheers! 

© Tasting Tequila with Brad

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:00] I recently reviewed the Calle Blanco and today we're moving on to their reposada. And this one gets interesting because we're talking about the same tequila, but putting it in oak for six months and seeing what the barrel does to it. Calle is produced nom 1424 Distalario di Agave Azul in San Juanito de Escaribo, Jalisco, with master distiller Zandra Gomez. They're using 100% blue Weber Agave. And one of the production methods I want to talk about is their extraction because they use a roller mill along with a screw mill system. I actually have some pictures here to see exactly what's happening. After the agave is cooked, the roller mill crushes it and shreds it, opening those fibers up, helping release those sugars. But if you look at this huge screw mill, the screw rotates and continually pushes the shredded cooked agave forward while putting pressure onto the fibrous material, almost like a giant mechanical press. This press helps squeeze out more of the sugary agave juice out of the fibers. The liquid separates through the screened and perforated section while the agave fibers, or boso, continues through the system. I think it's pretty cool because we talk all the time about the and roller mills, but you don't hear much about the screw mill. And the screw mill is actually doing a lot of the extraction from there. CA ferments in stainless steel tanks without any agave fibers. They use deep well water and they double distill before the reposado goes into a combination of American and French oak barrels for six months. It's then bottled at 40% ABV or 80 proof. And before we taste it, we have to talk about these bottles because these are a really cool story too. Calle's reposado bottle is made from recycled Pacifico beer bottles. And that recycled glass is the reason we have this distinctive color and look. These are handcrafted at a family owned artisanal glass factory right here in Jalisco. So you'll see little variations and imperfections from one bottle to the other. And that's really cool. It makes each bottle a little unique. Call takes sustainability idea beyond the glass, the cork, the hang tag, everything that is incorporated in this bottle is recycled. KAE really takes sustainability into their business and everything that they do. So their entire reposado packaging is being made with 100% recycled material. I love the glass, I love the story, and you know me, the packaging can be amazing. But ultimately I care about what's Inside, and that's the tequila. So let's dive into the nose of this one. I do get a nice cooked agave. I get a nice amount of caramel and a little bit of vanilla. There's also something there that's just a little herbal. And the longer I sit with the nose and smell it, I pick up almost a grassy note, and I want to say a little bit of citrus. So to me, it's kind of like a little bit of lemongrass that's mixed in with this nice caramel, vanilla oak note. All right, let's dive into the taste. [00:02:35] Has a nice mouth feel. Nice cooked agave. There's some nice pepper that heats up. This is definitely more complex than the blanco. I don't pick up anything unnatural. There's a nice sweetness. There's a nice little line of caramel, vanilla cooked agave. That lemongrass that I got on the nose really is a nice, grassy herbal note as it goes into a finish that is really kind of peppery and sweet with just a little hint of an oak. And then it starts to come a little dry as well. [00:03:04] On the second taste, I'd almost say there's a little citrus in there as well. I will say to me, reposado is a much better presentation than the blanco. Whatever the wood did here with that French and that American together has really changed some of that flavor profile in the finish. I'm actually picking up a. A really nice fruitiness and a nice, like, floral note as well. All right, so where do I land on this one? Really good repo. I like it. It has really nice flavors. It's very balanced, very rounded. The finish is nice and long. It's still really kind of hanging on there. So this is a nice one. Is it one that I would get again? Absolutely. This is not something that I would put in a cocktail. This is something I would actually sit and sip, and I would drink it neat. And cayenne has definitely created a bottle that gets your attention on the shelf. I respect the story behind it. Utilizing those recycled Pacifico bottles is pretty cool too. So my question to you. Have you tried this tequila? Would you drink it and let me know what your thoughts are? And I'm going to finish this one off and have a great evening. Cheers. Thanks for watching.

Other Episodes

Episode

November 28, 2025 00:03:37
Episode Cover

The Ultimate Still Strength Blind Test… The Winner SHOCKED Me!

Today I’m putting four of the most talked-about still strength tequilas into a completely blind showdown — Fortaleza Still Strength, Tapatio 110, Santo Fino...

Listen

Episode

May 06, 2026 00:59:29
Episode Cover

The Story Behind Paladar Tequila | Interview with Co-Founder Pete Nevenglosky

Paladar Tequila interview, Pete Nevenglosky interview, Paladar Tequila review, additive free tequila, tequila podcast, craft tequila, tequila tasting, high proof tequila, NOM 1109, tequila...

Listen

Episode

June 23, 2025 00:04:17
Episode Cover

Why I Don’t Have a Favorite Tequila | Best Tequila is the One I Poured Today

I get asked all the time: “What’s your favorite tequila?” In this video, I explain why I don’t have one. I taste new bottles...

Listen